A student from Olathe, Kansas, stood up at the 2010 Berkshire Hathaway meeting and asked how to find a circle of competence while still learning. Buffett didn’t tell the student to make it bigger.

He said to find the edge. The size of what you understand counts for less than knowing exactly where it stops, and most of us have never tested where ours stops. You want to find that line before money is involved, not after.

Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger, Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, May 1, 2010.

What is a circle of competence?

Your circle of competence is the set of businesses you can evaluate: you can say how they make money, what protects them and what could break them, with evidence and not with somebody else’s thesis. Everything outside it isn’t bad. You just can’t judge it yet.

Buffett’s first line to the student was about the edge, not the area:

“The biggest thing is not how big your circle of competence is, but knowing where the perimeter is.”

— Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, May 1, 2010

Then he took the pressure off. You don’t need an opinion on most companies.

“You don’t have to be an expert on 90 percent of the businesses, or 80 percent, or 70, or 50. But you do have to know something about the ones that you actually put your money into, and if that’s a very small part of the universe, that still is not a killer.”

— Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, May 1, 2010

A small circle is allowed. A circle you think is bigger than it is costs money, because those are the companies you buy with confidence you haven’t earned.

Familiarity is the usual way the circle gets inflated. Three levels look alike from the inside:

Level What you can say What’s still missing
Recognition “I know this company.” Anything beyond the name
Familiarity “I use the product every day.” The business behind the product
Evaluation “I can explain its economics and what could damage them.” Whether the evidence holds, and whether the price is right

Only the third one is inside the circle. Even there, an understandable business can be a poor investment at the wrong price.

Warren Buffett’s circle of competence quote

Buffett put the same idea in writing fourteen years before that meeting. The written version is the one most people quote:

“You don’t have to be an expert on every company, or even many. You only have to be able to evaluate companies within your circle of competence. The size of that circle is not very important; knowing its boundaries, however, is vital.”

— Warren Buffett, 1996 Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letter

The working word is “evaluate.” Recognizing a brand doesn’t count, and liking the product doesn’t either.

The boundary gives you permission to pass on a company without pretending it’s a bad one. “I can’t evaluate this” and “this is a bad business” are different conclusions, and only the first is honest most of the time. FatPitches has a button for it: Too hard.

The questions Buffett gave the student

Buffett didn’t hand the student a screener. He sent them home, to the businesses in Olathe, with four questions:

“Which would you like to buy into? Which do you think you could understand their economics? Which do you think will be around 10 or 20 years from now? Which do you think it would be very tough to compete with?”

— Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, May 1, 2010

Strip the hometown out and they still work on any listed company. Can you explain how it earns money? Can you say what keeps a competitor from taking that money? Can you name what would stop it from being around in 20 years?

His advice after that was plain: “Just keep asking yourself questions about businesses. Talk with other people about them. You will extend your knowledge over time.”

Short advice. Hard to do every day.

Circle of competence vs. “invest in what you know”

“Invest in what you know” goes wrong when “know” means “recognize.” Say you use a subscription software product every day. You know it solves a problem, your colleagues like it and switching would be a pain. Those are real observations, and none of them tells you what a new customer costs, whether customers renew without heavy discounts, how much the company spends to keep the product alive, or whether growth produces cash or eats it.

Your experience is where research starts. It isn’t the thesis.

Professional expertise has the same trap. As a software engineer I can read a product’s architecture in an afternoon, and that tells me nothing about who signs the purchase order at a bank or why they renew. Be precise about which questions your experience answers, and which it only makes you feel you could answer.

A real example: Buffett’s explanation of GEICO

In the same 1996 shareholder letter, Buffett explained GEICO as a loop:

  1. Low operating costs allowed low prices.
  2. Low prices attracted and kept policyholders.
  3. Policyholders referred other customers.
  4. Referrals lowered the cost of getting new ones, which kept costs low.

“GEICO sells car insurance” describes a product. The loop explains a business, because it shows how customer behavior turns into an advantage that feeds itself.

Look for that loop in anything you research. Then look for what would break it, because an advantage you can’t picture failing is one you don’t understand yet.

How to find your circle of competence

You don’t need a list of industries you understand. You need claims about specific companies that can be checked and can turn out wrong.

1. Start narrow

“I understand technology” is too broad to fail. “I understand how small accounting firms buy and use subscription software” names a customer, a problem and a context, so it can be tested.

2. Explain how money moves through the business

Write it in plain words: who pays and for what, why they choose this company over the alternatives, what drives revenue and the main costs, what must be reinvested just to stand still, and what could cut off the cash. “It benefits from a growing market” explains nothing about why this company should earn the profits.

3. Separate evidence from assumptions

For each important claim, name the evidence behind it.

Claim Evidence to look for
Customers tend to stay Retention disclosures, contract terms
Prices can rise Pricing history and how customers reacted
Growth creates value Acquisition costs, margins, reinvestment needs
Debt is manageable Maturities, obligations, cash generation
The company has an advantage Credible alternatives and competitors’ economics

An unanswered question stays an unanswered question. Don’t let it turn into an optimistic assumption while you’re not looking.

4. Write down how you could be wrong

What would make customers leave? Which cost could jump? Which valuation assumption carries the most weight? Write down the evidence that would change your mind, before you own the stock and start defending it.

The perimeter only shows up when you’re wrong

You can’t find your perimeter by reading about it. You find it the day you were sure and the annual report says otherwise.

Reading an explanation and nodding along feels like understanding. Committing to an answer before you see the explanation is the only version that tests anything. So I built a small daily exercise around exactly that commitment.

The Circle Daily deals five cards a day, the same five for everyone. Each card names a company and asks one of four questions, which are Buffett’s Olathe questions in another order: how does it make money, what protects it, what does growth cost it, what could damage it. Under the question sit three answers. All three are real lines from three real companies’ annual reports, and only one belongs to this company.

You pick one and say how sure you are: Sure, Guessing, or Too hard (no pick needed). Then the card turns over and shows whose line each answer was, with the quotes from the filing that rule the other two out.

What you said What it means for your circle
Sure, and right Inside, at least on this question
A guess, and right Luck until you can explain why
Sure, but wrong The perimeter. This one fooled you
Too hard An honest edge, marked on purpose

The row to keep is “Sure, but wrong.” It’s the exact spot where you thought the circle reached and it didn’t, which is the line Buffett told the student to find.

A right answer can still be a guess. A confident wrong answer is the most useful thing a card can show you.

How FatPitches scores honesty, not knowledge

I didn’t want a quiz that rewards knowing a lot. Buffett’s point is the opposite, so the Daily scores two other things.

The first is honesty: “when I’m sure, I’m right X%.” It stays hidden until you’ve given 20 Sure answers, because one lucky morning reads as 100%, and the badge is earned at 80%. The second is selectiveness, how often you say Too hard. It’s earned at 50%, and it only counts while your honesty badge holds, because passing on everything isn’t a skill either.

The punches are blue and orange, never red and green, because a miss is information and shouldn’t feel like a trading loss.

As a guest you can play every card, and the day lives in your browser tab until you close it. A free account keeps each day, so the streak, the honesty rate and the selectiveness rate build up over weeks. Your Daily answers on a company also show up as evidence when you research that company in FatPitches, next to your own answer to “Is this business inside your circle of competence?”

How to expand your circle of competence

Buffett’s answer to the student ended with an example from his own buying, and it’s the part people forget. The circle can grow, and you can sometimes act outside it, if the price does the protecting.

“I never had any idea that Korean stocks would be something that I would be buying. But I looked over there, and I could see that there were a number of businesses that met the margin of safety test. And there I diversified, because I didn’t know that much about any specific one, but I knew that a package of 20 was going to work out very well, even if a crook might run one of them, and a couple might run into competition I didn’t anticipate, because they were so cheap.”

— Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, May 1, 2010

Read it carefully, because it’s not a license to buy what you don’t understand. He knew he was outside the perimeter. He said so, he bought 20 instead of one, and he insisted on prices so low that a crook and a couple of surprises wouldn’t sink the basket. The margin of safety, the gap between the price you pay and a conservative estimate of what the business is worth, did the job his knowledge couldn’t.

Most of us should simply grow the circle slowly. Munger’s answer, right after Buffett’s, is the method:

“So you just have to get up each morning and try and go to bed that night a little wiser than you were when you got up.”

— Charlie Munger, Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, May 1, 2010

Study adjacent businesses

If you understand one subscription model, compare it with another serving similar customers. Note what transfers and what doesn’t: sales cycles, contracts, support costs, capital needs.

Compare competitors

Why are their margins different? Who competes on price? What does a customer give up by switching?

Write down the gaps

“I understood the product but not who controls the purchase” is a research question. “I need to learn more about this industry” isn’t.

Revisit when the business changes

An acquisition, a new pricing model or new debt can move a company back outside your circle. Ask whether you understand the business it’s becoming.

FatPitches keeps those notes per company in the conviction journal, where you track how your understanding of a business changes and Ben, the FatPitches AI analyst, supports and challenges it.

Understanding a business is not the same as finding a fat pitch

The circle answers the first question, not every question.

Concept Question it answers
Circle of competence Can I evaluate this business?
Competitive advantage What protects its economics?
Valuation What might it be worth, under assumptions I can write down?
Margin of safety Does the price leave room for being wrong?
Position size How much of my money, if any?

A familiar company can be overpriced. An understandable business can have weak economics. Settle whether you can evaluate the business first, then do the rest of the work.

That order is the point of Buffett’s fat pitch analogy: know your zone before deciding whether to swing. The full sequence is in the steps before buying a stock, and the price side of the Korean basket is in Rule No. 1, never lose money.

Common mistakes

Confusing confidence with evidence

A story can sound coherent and rest on one weak assumption. Ask what supports each claim, not whether the whole thing sounds right. The Daily’s “Sure, but wrong” row exists for this one.

Treating industry experience as investment expertise

Knowing how a hospital runs doesn’t tell you how a hospital chain is financed. Your knowledge can be real and limited at the same time.

Learning only enough to defend a purchase

Write the unknowns before you write the case for buying. Otherwise research turns into a search for reassurance.

Treating “too hard” as failure

Buffett told the student they had “the right attitude because you recognize your limitations.” Too hard means not today. You can come back, or spend the time on a business you can actually judge.

Frequently asked questions

What does circle of competence mean in simple terms?

It’s the set of businesses you can evaluate, plus an honest map of where that set ends. Buffett stresses knowing the edge over making the circle large.

Where did Buffett explain the circle of competence?

In writing, in the 1996 Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letter. Out loud, among other places, at the Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting of May 1, 2010, in the answer embedded above.

Is using a company’s products enough?

No. Using the product tells you something about customers. It doesn’t tell you about costs, financing, competition or price.

How do I know whether a company is inside my circle?

There’s no certificate. A useful test: commit to an answer about how it makes money, what protects it and what could damage it, then check against the annual report. If you were sure and wrong, it’s outside, for now.

Can my circle of competence grow?

Yes, slowly, by the “little wiser every day” method Munger described. Keep learning and buying apart: interest is a reason to research, not proof you’re ready to own it.

Does getting a daily card right mean I understand the stock?

No. It means you answered one question correctly, maybe by luck. That’s why the Daily asks how sure you were, and why the honesty rate only appears after 20 Sure answers.

Do I need an account to play?

No. Every card works as a guest. A free account keeps your days, your streak, your honesty and selectiveness rates, and shows your answers next to each company when you research it.

Five cards, one honest answer each

Buffett’s test for the student wasn’t how much they knew. It was whether they could tell what they knew from what he only recognized, and the only way to check is to commit before you see the answer.

Five questions a day from real annual reports, the same for everyone, no account needed to play: the Circle Daily. A free FatPitches account keeps the record of where your circle ends.

This article and the daily exercise are educational. Neither establishes investment suitability nor recommends buying or selling a security.